Friday, April 4, 2008

Book Review - Twilight Fall by Lynn Viehl

First off, let's start with the "truth in lending" disclosure:

I won an advance readers copy of this book on the author's blog (http://pbackwriter.blogspot.com/)

It is not the first book I've won on that site either. My wife first "met" the author through an online course she was teaching on http://www.fmwriters.com/ and we have several signed copies of her books as well as the majority of her back catalogue. However, we don't buy her books out of loyalty: we buy them because she's a darn good writer.

I first got "involved" with the Darkyn novels by either my wife or I (can't remember which at this point) winning a copy of the galley's before the release of the first book "If Angels Burn" before it was released to the public. We subsequently bought a copy of the book after it's release as well. So, I've been reading the series since it's inception.

With all that said, let's get to the book in specific and the series in general.

I'll start off by saying, this is not my favorite book in the series, though it is high up there. That honor belongs to it's immediate predecessor, Evermore (which I finally read two days before Twilight Fall.)

So why wasn't this my favorite book in the series? I personally felt Evermore was a more complete novel and romance. I also felt it stood alone much better than every other book in the series.

When you are writing a series, there are challenges for a writer: The first and foremost is to have a common thread between all the books. This can be as simple as following a main character as they move through life, or as complex as weaving a back story which both serves as a vehicle to introduce new characters as well as tell an overall story. Twilight Fall and the rest of the Darkyn novels fall in the latter category.

Given the genre (supernatural romance) there is the inevitable question: How does the series compare to Laurell K. Hamilton's "Anita Blake" series?

My personal answer is; there is no comparison.

I've read the majority of the Anita Blake series and, while they have their place, from a writing perspective you can't compare the two authors. The Anita Blake series is essentially a giant soap opera/soft moving toward hardcore pornography series which is both formulaic and, at best, adequately written/edited. Each book follows the same path (start a "mystery" with a brutal murder, spend the first 10% of the chapters on that, spend the next 80% on the main soap opera and then wrap up the mystery in a hurry in the last 10% of the book.) She's also in love with television and, for some reason thinks that ending a chapter, much as the scene before a commercial on television, with a "cliffhanger," is the way to keep your readers interested (it's not.)

The Darkyn series is not written like that. Each book is focused on a main romantic plot between characters who are connected to the overall "big picture," and, through their romance, more of the overall story is told. Yes, there are recurring characters who appear throughout the series, often on their own subplot, but their entrances and exits are both well thought out and don't come off as forced as well as they almost always (if not always) tie in to the main story/romance which is the focus of the particular book.

Twilight Fall, in particular, is definitely more of a "big picture" type of book. It may be it's one failing in as much as, unlike the other books in the series, this is not the book I could recommend to a first time Darkyn reader to start reading the series from. Not that it would confuse the reader, but rather that this book provides some answers to questions that have been teasing long time readers for quite some time. For readers of the series, this book definitely advances the overall back story in a very satisfying way.

I'm not going to get into specifics of the novel save for a few comments:

1. I don't think it was until Evermore that I really liked Michael Cyprien as a character. He was interesting, but, ultimately an arrogant stuffed shirt in my eyes. It's only been with Evermore and now Twilight Fall that I've started to both like him as a character, as well as start to see that, supernatural influence/ties aside, there might be someone there that Alexandra Keller could love.

2. The author asked people who might review the book to leave out the spoilers, one in particular (without actually mentioning it, which we as readers appreciate!) I'm certainly going to honor that. However, I do have to reiterate, especially for people who've been reading the series, this book is very much what we've been waiting for: A lot is revealed and questions are answered. We even get a glimpse of where (I presume) the series is going.

3. By the end of the book, I felt there was a scene missing. It's not a critical scene to the book in the overall big picture sense, and one that can certainly be played out in a later novel and may very well be better to have it's place later in the series. I won't go into details, but there was a scene of reconciliation that I would have liked to have seen happen by the end of the book (though not at the exact end of the book. The ending of the book is exactly where it needs to be.) It, like my "not for first time series readers" comment is a minor quibble.

Overall, Twilight Fall is exactly what I've come to expect from the author: Strong writing, a good, well paced story that keeps both the big picture as well as the individual romantic story well in focus.

I was entertained.